Bellman-Ford algorithm and SPFA algorithm for solving the shortest path problem

General
1

Both Bellman-Ford (BF) and Shortest Path Faster-Than-A*(SPFA)* are popular algorithms used to solve single-source
or multi-source shorted paths problems in a weighted graph. Here is an overview of both:

image
image507×505 65.5 KB

Bellman-Ford Algorithm:

  1. Initialization: Set the distance from source node s to all other nodes as infinity (or max value).
    Distance to itself for each vertex (v) will be zero.
  2. Relaxation Phase: For a total number of vertices minus one iterations, relax edges iteratively by updating
    distances if you find shorter paths through an edge (u,v) with weight w(u,v).
  3. Negative Cycle Detection (Optional): Check for negative cycles; perform extra iteration to confirm no
    further updates are possible.
  • Time Complexity: O(V*E), where V is vertices and E is edges.
  • Space Requirement: O(V).
  • Bellman-Ford can handle graphs with negative weights, but it cannot work efficiently on dense graph structures
    due its high time complexity (O(n^2)) for sparse ones compared to the other algorithms.

SPFA Algorithm:

  1. Initialization: Set all distances as infinite except source node s which is zero.
  2. Queue Setup and Initial Queue Filling: Initialize a queue with only starting point/sources vertex(s) that
    are being processed (in BFS style).
  3. Relaxation Phase & Repeated Relaxations using the Priority Queued structure:
    • Process vertices one by processing queues until all reachable nodes/vertices from sources have been visited.
    • Check each node in order of priority, i.e., shortest distance discovered so far for a given vertex; relax
      adjacent edges and update their neighbors with new shorter paths (if found).
  4. Termination: If after several iterations there are no updates to be made on queue contents implying that
    all reachable nodes have been processed up till the longest path possible from source(s) s within graph has
    finished processing.
  • Time Complexity: O(E + V*logV), where E is edges and V is vertices; it performs better than Bellman-Ford due
    its quicker convergence properties for sparse graphs.
  • Space Requirement: Similar to BF, but with the additional requirement of maintaining a priority queue that
    increases overhead significantly in dense graph structures.
    image
    image649×462 68.2 KB

In conclusion:

Advantages:

  1. Bellman-Ford Algorithm: Handles negative weights and can detect cycles (negative ones) efficiently which
    makes it versatile across varying edge weight configurations.
  2. SPFA Algorithm: Shorter time complexity for sparse graphs, better convergence speed compared to
    Bellman-Ford due its priority queue implementation.

Disadvantages:

  1. Both algorithms may require significant overhead in dense graph structures; SPFA’s additional memory
    requirement can slow down processing significantly when dealing with larger datasets.
  2. Spanning Tree formation (i.e., finding all shortest paths simultaneously) is not naturally handled by either
    algorithm requiring further optimization or combination to achieve this functionality.

Both Bellman-Ford and Shortest Path Faster-Than-A*(SPFA)* are fundamental in solving single-source/multi-source
path problems, with the choice of usage dependent on graph structure characteristics (sparse/dense),
presence/absence negative weights/cycles.